For most situations, yes. Tooth-coloured bonded fillings preserve more healthy tooth structure, match your enamel, and seal to the tooth rather than simply wedging into it. Amalgam still lasts longer in very large restorations under heavy chewing load.
This is a routine question and not an urgent one. Sound amalgam fillings don’t need replacing, and removing healthy ones unnecessarily removes more tooth. Our dental services in Bolton are amalgam-free for new work, with existing fillings assessed on their condition rather than their material.
Here’s the distinction that actually matters clinically, and it isn’t mercury.
Amalgam is held in place mechanically, so the cavity has to be cut into a shape that grips it, which means removing sound tooth. Composite bonds chemically, so only the decay comes out. Over a lifetime of repeat treatment that difference compounds into whether a tooth eventually needs a crown.
The materials compared
| Amalgam (silver) | Composite (bonded) | |
|---|---|---|
| Appearance | Silver, darkens over time | Matched to your tooth |
| Tooth removed | More, for mechanical retention | Only the decay |
| Bonds to tooth | No | Yes |
| Typical lifespan | 10 to 15 years | 7 to 10 years |
| Strengthens remaining tooth | No | Somewhat |
| Sensitivity to technique | Low | Higher, needs a dry field |
| Expansion with temperature | Yes, can crack teeth over time | Minimal |
| Best suited to | Very large back restorations | Most cavities, all visible teeth |
Composite’s shorter average lifespan is worth being honest about. The counterweight is that replacing a composite usually means another composite, while a tooth repeatedly restored with amalgam tends to need a crown eventually.
What about the mercury question?
Worth addressing directly and without drama.
Dental amalgam contains mercury bound into an alloy with silver, tin and copper. Major health authorities, including Health Canada, have concluded that amalgam is not a cause of illness in the general population, and there is no recommendation to remove sound amalgam fillings.
Use has still declined worldwide, for two main reasons. The Minamata Convention commits countries to phasing down mercury use for environmental reasons, and composite materials have improved considerably in strength and wear resistance.
Some groups are advised toward alternatives as a precaution, including pregnant and breastfeeding patients, young children, and people with kidney conditions or a known allergy to amalgam components.
So the honest position is that amalgam-free dentistry is a reasonable default for reasons of tooth preservation and appearance, rather than because existing fillings pose a danger.
When an old filling genuinely needs replacing
- Decay at the margin, visible on an X-ray as a shadow beneath or beside it
- A crack in the filling or the surrounding tooth
- A ditch or step at the edge that catches floss
- The filling standing proud of worn enamel around it
- Sensitivity or pain on biting that tracks to that tooth
- A broken cusp beside a large restoration
- A bad taste or odour localised to that area
What isn’t on that list: being silver. A 15-year-old amalgam with sound margins and no decay beneath it is doing its job, and replacing it means cutting more tooth away for a cosmetic gain.
Where decay has reached the nerve, root canal therapy comes before any filling discussion.
What getting a bonded filling involves
- Numbing, unless the cavity is very shallow.
- Removing the decay conservatively, keeping sound tooth structure.
- Isolating the tooth so it stays dry. Composite will not bond properly to a wet surface, and this step largely determines how long the filling lasts.
- Etching and applying bonding agent to create a chemical seal.
- Placing the composite in thin layers, each cured with a light.
- Shaping and checking the bite, including the contact point with the neighbouring tooth.
- Polishing, which affects both appearance and how readily it stains.
Step 3 is why bonded fillings are more technique-sensitive. A composite placed in a poorly isolated field fails early, which is behind much of the reputation for shorter lifespan.
One sequencing note: if you’re planning teeth whitening, do it before any visible filling is placed. Composite doesn’t lighten with whitening gel, so matching it to your current shade locks the colour in.
Discussing options in Bolton
Bolton Park Dentistry is at 14 Parr Blvd Unit 5, Bolton, Ontario L7E 4H1, serving Bolton and surrounding communities in a calm environment built to ease anxiety.
We’re accepting new patients and offer same-day appointments when available. Alongside amalgam-free and bonded fillings, we provide hygiene and preventive care, crowns, bridges, extractions, root canal therapy, implant restoration, porcelain veneers, teeth whitening, athletic sports guards, TMJ and TMD therapy and non-surgical gum therapy, with sedation available for anxious patients and free consultations for implants and braces.
Call 647-496-2336, email reception@boltonparkdentistry.com, or reach us through the contact page. All dentists here are licensed and registered with the Royal College of Dental Surgeons of Ontario, and decisions about replacing existing fillings are made from your X-rays rather than general guidance.
Frequently asked questions
Should I replace my old silver fillings?
Not if they’re sound. Health authorities advise against removing intact amalgam fillings, because replacement removes additional tooth structure for no clinical gain. Replacement is indicated for decay, cracks or failing margins.
Are white fillings as strong as silver?
Modern composites handle normal chewing forces well in small and medium cavities. For very large restorations in molars, amalgam or a crown may still last longer, and your dentist will advise where the cavity size makes that relevant.
Do composite fillings stain?
They can over several years, particularly at the edges and with coffee, tea, red wine or smoking. Good polishing slows it, and surface staining can often be polished off at a hygiene appointment rather than requiring replacement.
Why is my new filling sensitive to cold?
Mild sensitivity for a few weeks is common after a deeper filling, as the nerve settles. Sensitivity that worsens, lingers for more than a minute, or appears on biting should be checked, as the bite may need adjusting.
Is amalgam removal risky?
Removal does release some mercury vapour, which is why protective measures such as high-volume suction and isolation are used. This is another reason sound fillings are generally left alone rather than removed electively.
Conclusion
Bonded tooth-coloured fillings preserve more tooth and look better, which is why they’re the default for new work. Sound amalgam fillings should be left in place rather than replaced for appearance alone. Decay, cracks and failing margins are what justify replacement, and an X-ray shows which you have.